Echeveria Blue Bird Brown Spot

Brown Or Black Spots On Succulents- 5 Reasons Why

Although most succulents are hardy plants they are still prone to pests and diseases. Because of the large, water filled leaves and vibrant colours damage caused by various factors can become very noticeable.

But what does cause brown or black marks/ spots on succulents?

Unfortunately, there are many causes to brown/black spots on succulents. Pests such as mealy bugs, aphids or slugs, fungus, rot, burns from the sun, warts from too much water, the equivalent of frost bite, any puncture marks or scratches.

It may be hard to identify what brown/black spot is caused by which factor. We have seen them all at our small plant nursery and will try our best to provide good photos and descriptions for each factor.

Pests

Pests that feed on succulents range from tiny aphids to bigger snails, slugs, caterpillars, grasshoppers to larger animals such as mice, birds, possums, kangaroos or deer. The large animals will take big chunks, but small insects and pests will only make tiny marks in the foliage and stalk which will end up darkening in colour and becoming brown or black as the plant heals (like a scab on a human body). The only difference is that the ‘scab’ on a succulent is there permanently. The only way the plant will loose it is to grow out of it.  

The worst culprits for causing black/brown spots on succulents are aphids, mealy bugs and young slugs and snails. Aphids and mealies also secrete a sticky sap that can sometimes stick to the plants worsening the look. To make things even worse they tend to hide in the most tender growth (new leaves). By feeding on the new growth they make marks into something that is going to grow bigger and take longer to grow out of.

So what to do about small pests making ugly marks on your succulents? Unfortunately it is pretty much inevitable that any/all of these little pests will attack your succulents at some stage. They are extremely widespread and fast to invade. The most important thing is to act fast and not leave them, hoping they will eventually disappear. Even a day or two of delaying can mean many more hundreds if not thousands of aphids/mealy bugs waiting to hatch and unleash on your plants.

Aphids are quite easy to kill by using pyrethrum based sprays. If you notice them (they come in a green, brown, black and even orange) on your plants and there is not that many, they can just be squashed with a toothpick and washed off. Also isolate the plant from the rest until you are satisfied there are no more. Large infestations may need to be dealt with pesticides. We would like to stress that a lot of pesticides can kill many beneficial insects too and this is not good. Beneficial insects are struggling and we need to do what we can to protect them. Without beneficial insetcts & pollinators humans will have a tough time growing crops. Even small things like spraying after dark when the good bugs are no longer flying can make a big difference. We usually isolate the plants in a shed and spray there. Eco-neem or oil can be tried but so far it has not worked for us when there are quite a few aphids present.

Mealy Bugs are a tough one as they can become resistant to pesticides and have a woolly cover to protect them. They are also masters at hiding and can position themselves in the tightest of spots between leaves and stem, in curled up, dried leaves, under the lip of the pot, under the table, under any debris found around their food source. They can lay their eggs (anywhere between 300-600) out of sight but close to the plants so when the little nymphs hatch, they don’t have far to crawl. In their early days, mealy bugs can be quite fast and can cover a fair distance, which will see them spread over several plants. Controlling mealy bugs is very hard. Early detection and isolation is best. Also keeping your plant area clean, if your succulents are grown in pots. If only one or two are found, squashing with a toothpick/ thin skewer is your best option. The infected plant and any other surrounding plants will need to be thoroughly checked (pull leaves apart, take out of pot to make sure there are no mealy bugs on roots etc.). Isolate the infected plant and monitor for a couple of weeks for any further outbreaks. If you have found multiple mealy bugs that are hard to reach/ there are too many to squash they can be sprayed with a 70% rubbing alcohol or isopropyl solution. Each mealy bug will need to be doused and then washed off. We have tried numerous pesticides claiming to control mealy bugs but they seldom work and they are also horribly toxic to other insects as well as yourselves. 70% alcohol solution seems to do the trick, but may need multiple applications and monitoring as even this is not 100% effective. The majority of succulents are prone to mealy bugs and so if you have a nice collection with some expensive plants, regular checks and cleanliness are a must.

graptosedum mealy bug damage

This Graptosedum is growing out of its mealy bug damage

Echeveria Emerald Ripple Mealy Bug Damage

I have kept this Echeveria Emerald Ripple especially with this article in mind. It was tucked away under it's 'mom' and got badly infested with mealy bugs while still quite small. This is the damage they have caused and it will take a few months before all the leaves with the brown warts and marks will grow out.

Sempervivum Oddity mealy bug damage

Another Mealy Bug victim. I have only recently killed the mealies on this Sempervivum Oddity. The black marks in-between the leaves are where they fed.

When talking about mealy bugs and aphids, we also have to mention ants as they are often a direct result of these pests appearing and thriving. Ants spread and ‘farm’ these pests as they produce a sugary honeydew which ants collect. Ants also protect mealies and aphids (some scale insects too) from predators such as parasitic wasps or ladybugs. We have read some fascinating articles on ant behaviour and their relationship with pests here and here. This relationship between ants and pests is however killing your (and our) plants. In our opinion ants are a pest as well and need to be stopped from reaching plants. This is harder than it sounds as ants always find a way and can infest pretty much any part of the garden very fast. Chemicals will only kill the workers (and scores of other insects too). There are recipes online for borax and sugar lures which are meant to be collected by ants and brought over to the nest and fed to the queen (who produces all these gazillions of eggs under ground). We have never had success with this or any other green solution. The best way for us is to keep the ground clean and spray any ants in our nursery area with a pyrethrum based spray.

Slugs and snails will make little holes into succulents foliage that will then heal into a series of dark coloured marks. They can hide in tight crevices or under pots/rocks/moist dark spots and come out at night which makes them difficult to catch. With slugs and snails the green elminiation techniques work quite well. Our favourite is to bury a shallow dish of beer into the ground and the slugs will obligingly drink themselves to death.

aeonium slug damage

These brown marks were caused by a slug. We have also found him hiding under the pot.

slug hiding under pot

The naughty slug that has caused the damage above 

Fungus, Rot & Water Warts

Fungus infection, rot & warts from over-watering in succulents are quite common, especially in humid & warm parts of the world. Many succulents come from dry and arid environments and dislike humidity. Even plants that are kept under cover and are not watered often can fall prey to a fungal infection if there is a lot of moisture in the air.

Fungal infections in succulents create black or brown, usually round spots that can grow to colonize the whole leaf which then tends to fall off and shrivel. Sometimes there are only one or two spots per plant, sometimes many more. The spots can also develop a wart or kind of a scab. All of these need to be acted on by a fungicide which are easily obtainable from garden centres, online and even big grocery stores. Most fungicides can harm beneficial insects and so it is best to either spray in the evening when they are not active or make your own. We have found this recipe that is harmless and made out of ingredients found in most kitchens.

Fungal infection on succulent leaf

This is a fungal infection on an Aeonium leaf.

pachyphytum fittkaui fungal infection

Fungal Infection on Pachyphytum Fittkaui

Fungus on echeveria colorata

All the spots on this Echeveria are caused by a Fungus

Fungus on succulents

More Fungal disease

During high humidity seasons it is recommended that fungicide is applied every other week. Although limiting water in an already humid environment can be a good idea with some succulents, in others it can stress them too much and cause shrivelled leaves. We would recommend that succulents get watered once a week when very hot (the potting mix should be dry between waterings). Do not spray succulents with water, this will not do them any favours as they are not able to absorb water through their leaves. It is best that water is administered around the root area in sensitive succulents. Always use succulent potting mix or other well-draining mix in pot plants. Heavy potting mix that holds on to water will only make things worse.

warts on echeveria bloody maria

Spot the succulent with fungus! Echeveria Bloody Maria (right) is particularly prone to over-watering and humidity and will develop warts and dark marks from fungus very easily.

Some succulents are more prone to fungus than others. We have had problems with many Echeverias, some Graptopetalums, Graptoverias, Pachyverias and Pachyphytums. There are plants in these genera such as Echeveria Black Knight, Echeveria Purpurosum, Graptoveria Amethorum & Pachyphytum Fittkaui that almost without a fail get fungus as soon as we’ve had a few days of rain, followed by hot and humid weather. It is a bit slower to attack and can be eliminated if the plants are under cover and do not get rained on. Curiously, some (not all) sensitive plants such as the ones mentioned above do not seem to have this problem if planted in the ground. We do not know why.

If your plant is rotting and you notice the root, stem & leaves going black (sometimes mushy) there is not much that can be done. If the rot has not yet reached the top part of the plant and leaves are not affected, it can be cut off from the rotting bit and planted as a cutting.

Echeveria Lola Rot

Rot can be hard to detect. Sometimes there are warning black marks, sometimes the plant all of a sudden collapses just like this Lola.  Nothing can be done to save the plant at this stage.

Sunburn

Yes, unfortunately succulents can get sunburn. Different succulents have different tolerance levels to sun, but most get some kind of a burn once the temperature starts climbing over 40C (104F). We always point this out- it is important to remember that the forecast temperatures are shade temperatures. If you were to put a thermometer in full sun during the hottest part of the day, you’d record much more than what the forecast says. And this is what plants have to deal with, so there is little wonder that even tough plants such as succulents get burns. If a human spent an hour in such strong sun without protective clothing and sunscreen the burns would probably put them in hospital.

Our little nursery is west of Sydney and we regularly see temperatures climbing over 40C which would cause burn marks on foliage of most of our potted succulents. Plants in the garden do remarkably well and have much higher tolerance. We think this is because the roots can stay a lot cooler in the ground than in pots.

Succulents can react differently to extremely hot sun. Some may drop leaves, some can collapse in a heap of mush and some will get obvious dark coloured marks or spots. As with all of the above, the marks will not disappear once the plant suffered a burn, but the plant will in time grow out of the wounds.

Echeveria Perle Von Nurnberg sunburn

This Echeveria Perle Von Nurnberg has got sunburnt on a 45C (113F) day. It is slowly growing out of its wounds.

Sunburnt succulent
Sunburnt Succulent

Another heatwave casualty

To prevent burns pot plants can be moved to shade when heatwaves are expected. We pull a 30% shadecloth over ours. If pots are too hard to move, an umbrella or some kind of cloth can be pitched over. Same can be done for succulents in the ground. We leaves ours to deal with the weather but inevitably some do get dark marks as a result of sun damage.

Frost

Frost can have similar effects on succulents like the sun. Dark spots can develop on the foliage as a result of frost. If too severe, succulents will collapse.

To protect succulents from mild frosts a frost cloth can be placed over the plants. Apart from a few plants such as Sempervivums, succulents are not frost tolerant and so if you live in a country with cold winters that can see snow settle for several days, succulents may not survive outside even with a frost cloth over and should be brought inside until the danger of frosts passes.

Our plants stay outdoors as we very rarely get any frost and most succulents are ok if the temperatures do not dip below 0 Celsius (32F). Frost cloth is enough for us to get the plants through the coldest of winter.

Puncture Marks & Scratches

Just like tiny pests can cause brown/ black spots by feeding from succulents leaves scratching the surface of the leaves can result in dark spots forming on the plants. This can happen if something falls on the succulents, when the foliage is damaged while re-potting or through hail damage. Some succulents are more prone to black/brown puncture marks and scratches than others. This is not always a rule but more frequently than not plants that have a good, thick coating of farina (the dusty coating on the leaves and stems) get marked more easily.

brown spot on cotyledon

In an unfortunate accident a small Y shaped branch fell on this Cotyledon Tomentosa causing small punctures. These have now healed into brown spots.

The prevention here is obvious- handle succulents with care and do not rub the leaves. Once the damage is done the only way the spots are going to go away is by growing out of them.  

If you can think of other reasons for Black/ Brown spots on succulents, leave a comment below 🙂